How to pick fair teams for a small-sided game
Nobody enjoys a 9-2. Five ways to split players into balanced teams, from captains' picks to ratings, plus how to fix an uneven match while it is being played.
Every regular game has the same scene: fourteen people gather by the pitch and someone asks ‘how are we splitting?’ Twenty minutes later it is 6-0, the losing side has stopped trying and the winners are bored. Badly picked teams waste the hour for everyone. The recipe for a good game is simple: going into the last five minutes, the result should still be in doubt.
Why balance is difficult
Because balance is not just the sum of ability. Two good forwards on one side can be matched by two good defenders on the other, but a team with no goalkeeper will lose whatever its best players do. Four things decide it:
- Ability. Players who are comfortable on the ball and can pass and shoot.
- Fitness. Those still running in the last twenty minutes. On a small pitch this often matters more than skill.
- Position. Players willing to go in goal or stay in defence are scarce and should not end up on the same side.
- Familiarity. Three friends who have played together for years will beat three stronger strangers.
Five ways to pick teams
1. Captains' picks
Two captains choose in turn. It is the best-known method and usually gives balanced sides because the captains know the players. It has two problems: the captain who picks first has an advantage, and being picked last is not pleasant.
The answer to the first is a ‘snake’ order: the first captain takes one, the second takes two, then the first takes two (1-2-2-2…). That evens out the first pick.
2. Ratings
Each player gets a mark from 1 to 5 and the teams are built so the totals match. It is the fairest method for groups that play regularly. It helps if two or three people set the ratings together and update them every few weeks. They do not need to be public; the organiser knowing them is enough.
3. Pairing
Players of similar level are paired off and one of each pair goes to each side. The two goalkeepers, the two best players and the two quickest are split. It is a quick, spoken version of ratings and can be done at the side of the pitch in two minutes.
4. Random
Handing out bibs, splitting by surname or tossing a coin. It is fast and nobody is offended, but balance is left to chance. If you pick at random, be ready to swap players after the first ten minutes.
5. A fixed core
Each side keeps two or three permanent players and the rest are shared out week by week. In long-running groups it builds rivalry and understanding. The risk is one side starting to win every week; then the cores need reshuffling.
| Method | Time | Balance | When to use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Captains' picks | 3–4 minutes | Good | Groups where players know each other |
| Ratings | Prepared in advance | Very good | Regular weekly groups |
| Pairing | 2 minutes | Good | A quick fix at the pitch |
| Random | 30 seconds | Down to luck | New or mixed groups |
| Fixed core | None | Can drift over time | Long-running, competitive groups |
Split goalkeepers and defenders first
The most common mistake is to look at the attackers and forget the defence. If there are two willing goalkeepers, put them on opposite sides before anything else. If there is only one, balance it by giving the other team a rotating-keeper rule or an extra good player.
The same goes for those who like to defend. Four forwards on one side and four defenders on the other will not produce an even game; the first team will be caught on the counter all night.
Fixing the balance during the match
Despite every care the teams can still be uneven. If it is 4-0 after ten minutes, do not wait:
- 1Swap a player. Exchange the winning side's most effective player for one from the losing side. One swap is usually enough.
- 2Reset the score. Starting again at 0-0 after the swap brings everyone back into the game.
- 3Play short matches. Instead of one hour-long game, play three of twenty minutes. A player or two changes sides after each, and a badly picked team lasts twenty minutes at most.
Write the teams down and share them
Deciding the teams before the match and sending them to the group removes ten minutes of negotiation at the pitch. When everyone knows which side and which position they are playing, the game starts on time. Keep the weekly lineups and you will gradually see which combinations give the closest matches.
Starting shapes to try on the pitch
Open this setup, then change the players and make it your own.
Open this setup, then change the players and make it your own.
Set out both teams and send them to the group
Type in the names, choose a shape and share the lineup image before the match.
More articles
5-a-side tactics: the 2-2, 1-2-1 and 2-1-1 formations compared
Four outfield players and a goalkeeper: which shape suits your team? The 2-2, 1-2-1 and 2-1-1 compared with diagrams, strengths and weaknesses.
Goalkeepers in small-sided football: fixed, rotating or fly keeper?
Nobody wants to go in goal, yet the goalkeeper usually decides the match. Rules for rotating keepers, the case for a fixed one and how to use a fly keeper.
The best 7-a-side and 8-a-side formations (with diagrams)
Eleven-a-side formations don’t work on a small pitch. The 7-a-side and 8-a-side shapes that actually hold up, when to use each one, and how to stop conceding on the break.