Penalty shootouts: who should take them, and in what order?

Luck or preparation? We simulated 2,000 knockout matches: how many go to penalties, what share of kicks are scored and how to order your five takers.

DDreamerBuild4 min read

A hundred and twenty minutes are over and the score is level. The coach stands among the players with a sheet of paper, looking for five names. Some look away, some raise a hand. Who those five are, and in what order they kick, may be one of the most important decisions of the season. It is easy to call it a lottery; but even in a lottery you decide how many tickets you hold.

How often do matches go to penalties?

We simulated Fenerbahçe v Galatasaray 2,000 times on neutral ground as a knockout tie, with extra time and penalties on:

MeasureResult
Matches going to extra time27.4%
Matches going to penalties14.0%
Average kicks per shootout11.1
Share of shootout kicks scored75.7%
Fenerbahçe's shootout win rate49.3%
Neutral venue, default starting XIs, 2,000 simulations.

More than a quarter of balanced knockout ties go to extra time and about one in seven to penalties. For a team preparing for a cup match, that is not a possibility to ignore.

The second striking number is in the last row: once it reaches a shootout, the win rate is almost exactly even. Squad differences that matter over ninety minutes largely disappear from the spot. About three in four kicks are scored, which is close to the general rate in real football.

Who belongs in the first five?

The best penalty takers are not always the best players. Three qualities matter:

  • A clean strike. Players who can hit the ball hard and accurately, whatever their position. A centre-back who strikes it well is safer than a nervous winger.
  • Composure. Players who have taken penalties in matches and do not change their mind under pressure.
  • Freshness. A player who has run for 120 minutes and is cramping will strike it worse. A good taker who came on late is often more reliable.

That is why some coaches make a substitution in the last minute of extra time purely for the shootout. With five changes allowed, the move is easier than it used to be, provided one has been kept back.

Deciding the order

There are two common approaches, and both have sound reasoning.

Best first

The most reliable takers go in the first three places. The reason: the shootout may never reach a fifth kick. Put your best taker fifth and he may not touch the ball if it ends on the fourth. Early goals also put pressure on the opponent.

Best fifth

The most reliable name is saved for the last kick, where the pressure is greatest. The risk is described above. Most analysis therefore favours the first approach; placing your two best takers first and third, or first and fourth, is a good compromise.

PlaceWhoWhy
1Most reliable takerA good start settles the shootout
2Composed player with sound techniqueOpens a gap if the opponent has missed
3Second-best takerThe third kick is often the turning point
4Experienced playerPressure rises, so you need someone who will not change his mind
5Cool finisherIf it comes, the kick that wins or saves the tie
There is no single correct order; what matters is that it is decided before the match.

After the fifth kick

If the scores are level after five kicks each, the shootout continues one kick at a time and everyone on the pitch takes a turn, goalkeeper included. An average shootout of 11 kicks means the sixth and seventh takers are often needed. Naming five and leaving the rest to chance is a common mistake; prepare an order for all eleven.

The goalkeeper's share

If three in four kicks are scored, a goalkeeper saves one or two in an average shootout. That is enough to win it. A good shootout goalkeeper knows the opposing takers, waits on the line as long as possible and makes the taker think. His own kick has to be planned as well: in a long shootout his turn comes.

Penalties in the simulator

There are two routes in DreamerBuild: play a knockout match to the end, or open the penalty shootout mode directly. Each kick is played individually. You can choose your penalty taker in the match settings; if that player is no longer on the pitch, the engine picks the most suitable one. Playing the same shootout several times with different orders gives you an idea of who should go first.

Starting shapes to try on the pitch

Real Madrid · 4-3-3dreamerbuild.com1Courtois9Mbappé11Junior7Diomande8Valverde10Camavinga6Tchouaméni3Cucurella2Alexander-Arnold4Huijsen5Konaté
Build a lineup with this shape

Open this setup, then change the players and make it your own.

Barcelona · 4-2-3-1dreamerbuild.com1García9Raphinha11Gordon7Yamal10López8Pedri6de Jong3Balde2Koundé4Cubarsí5García
Build a lineup with this shape

Open this setup, then change the players and make it your own.

Play a shootout yourself

Build your lineup, choose your penalty taker and watch the shootout kick by kick.

Open the simulator

More articles

Positions & Tactics•15 November 2026

How the offside rule works: the line, the moment of the pass and VAR

An offside position and an offside offence are not the same thing. The three conditions, the situations people confuse, the offside trap and what the VAR line measures, with a diagram.

4 min readRead
Barcelona · 4-2-3-1dreamerbuild.com1García9Raphinha11Gordon7Yamal10López8Pedri6de Jong3Balde2Koundé4Cubarsí5García
Positions & Tactics•15 November 2026

Striker types: target man, false nine, runner and poacher

Four different centre-forwards, four different teams. What each type does, who should play alongside and which one suits your squad, with a comparison table.

4 min readRead
Real Madrid · 4-3-3dreamerbuild.com1Courtois9Mbappé11Junior7Diomande8Valverde10Camavinga6Tchouaméni3Cucurella2Alexander-Arnold4Huijsen5Konaté
Positions & Tactics•15 November 2026

Midfield roles: what the 6, the 8 and the 10 actually do

The holding midfielder, the box-to-box player and the playmaker do three different jobs in the same area. Their tasks, the common trios and how to pick a balanced midfield, with a diagram.

4 min readRead