How much is home advantage worth? We played seven fixtures 21,000 times
The same two squads at three venues. Seven big fixtures simulated a thousand times each at home, on neutral ground and away: what home advantage is worth, and when it does nothing.
‘We're at home’ is said in football almost as if it were a tactic. But how much difference does the venue really make? In the DreamerBuild match engine that is easy to measure: you can play the same two squads with the same settings and change only the venue. We simulated seven fixtures a thousand times at each of three venues, 21,000 matches in all.
How the experiment was set up
- Three scenarios per fixture: home, neutral and away, each of 1,000 matches.
- Squads from the site's 2026-27 data with default starting XIs and formations.
- Clear weather, injuries on, extra time off (draws possible).
- With a thousand matches, rates move by roughly ±3 points; read the small gaps below with that in mind.
Results: win rate of the first-named team
| Fixture | At home | Neutral | Away | Home–away gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fenerbahçe v Galatasaray | 39.5% | 32.3% | 22.8% | 16.7 pts |
| Real Madrid v Barcelona | 46.2% | 37.0% | 29.3% | 16.9 pts |
| Liverpool v Arsenal | 40.7% | 32.7% | 23.1% | 17.6 pts |
| Bayern v Dortmund | 60.8% | 55.0% | 43.8% | 17.0 pts |
| Inter v Milan | 52.2% | 47.1% | 32.0% | 20.2 pts |
| Beşiktaş v Trabzonspor | 46.2% | 43.0% | 33.4% | 12.8 pts |
| Manchester City v Konyaspor | 86.7% | 87.8% | 85.6% | 1.1 pts |
The first six rows are consistent: the gap between playing at home and playing away is 13 to 20 points. Moving from neutral ground to home adds six or seven points to the win rate on average, and going away takes about as much off.
In a balanced match the venue changes everything
El Clásico is the clearest case. On neutral ground the teams are exactly level, 37% each. At home Real Madrid lead 46% to 28%; at Barcelona the picture flips to 29% against 44%. With equal squads, the stadium alone decides who is favourite.
Fenerbahçe v Galatasaray and Liverpool v Arsenal look similar: the visiting squad is ahead on neutral ground (43% to 32%), and being at home reverses the balance.
The effect on goals
The venue shifts goals as well as results. In Real Madrid v Barcelona the home side averages 1.70 goals at home, 1.43 on neutral ground and 1.31 away. The opponent's average runs 1.26, 1.44 and 1.63 in the same order. Roughly, home advantage adds 0.2 to 0.3 goals a match to the home side and takes about as much from the visitors.
The gap in shots is smaller: about one more a match for the home team. The difference comes from the quality of chances rather than their number.
The match where home advantage does nothing
The last row tells a different story. The gap between Manchester City's squad and Konyaspor's is so large that the venue changes almost nothing: City win 86.7% at home and 85.6% away. One point is less than the sampling noise.
The lesson is that home advantage is a fixed push, not a multiplier. It tips a balanced match and disappears in a lopsided one. Playing at home does not make the weaker team favourite; it only narrows the gap a little.
What about real football?
In real leagues, too, home teams win clearly more often than visitors; it is one of the oldest and most consistent findings in football statistics. The usual explanations are crowd support, travel, familiarity with the pitch and small tendencies in refereeing. During periods played without spectators the advantage shrank without vanishing.
The simulation does not model any of those causes separately; it treats home advantage as a general boost to the home side's strength. The figures here are therefore not predictions for real matches but a measurement of how much weight the engine gives the venue.
What it means for your lineup
- Plan away matches separately. The same eleven loses 13 to 20 points of win rate away. A more compact shape or a front line built for the counter can recover part of it.
- Look at a series, not one match. Even a thousand matches move by ±3 points; a single simulated score tells you nothing about the venue.
- If you are a heavy favourite, the venue will not save or sink you. When the squad gap is large, changing the XI moves the result; changing the stadium does not.
Starting shapes to try on the pitch
Open this setup, then change the players and make it your own.
Open this setup, then change the players and make it your own.
Play the same match at three venues
Pick two teams, switch the venue between home, neutral and away and see the difference with your own lineup.
More articles
We simulated Beşiktaş v Galatasaray 1,000 times: who has the edge at Tüpraş?
Ahead of the 30 November derby we played Beşiktaş v Galatasaray a thousand times at each of three venues: win rates, common scores, top scorers and home advantage.
Real Madrid–Barcelona: a 3,000-match experiment with open records
Two fixed lineups, three venues, 3,000 simulations. Explore the results, exact squads, uncertainty and downloadable match records from our Clásico experiment.
Rain, wind and snow: how weather changes a football match
We played the same Clásico a thousand times each in clear weather, rain, wind and snow. How goals, pass accuracy and shots changed, and how to pick a team for bad weather.