We simulated Beşiktaş v Galatasaray 1,000 times: who has the edge at Tüpraş?
Ahead of the 30 November derby we played Beşiktaş v Galatasaray a thousand times at each of three venues: win rates, common scores, top scorers and home advantage.
Beşiktaş host Galatasaray at Tüpraş Stadium on Monday 30 November, in week 13 of the Süper Lig. Before the derby we used the DreamerBuild match engine to play the same two squads a thousand times at each of three venues, 3,000 matches in all. The aim is not to predict the match, but to see how much the gap between the squads, the venue and luck move the outcome.
How we did it
- Squads come from the site's 2026-27 data, using the builder's default starting XI and formation for both sides: Beşiktaş 4-3-3, Galatasaray 4-2-3-1.
- Clear weather, injuries on; both teams on a balanced mentality, medium pressing and balanced tempo.
- Matches lasted 90 minutes with no extra time or shootout, so draws are possible.
- Each scenario ran 1,000 times and every match has its own recorded random seed (19 November 2026). Running it again with the same settings gives the same results.
| Beşiktaş (4-3-3) | Galatasaray (4-2-3-1) |
|---|---|
| Nübel | Uğurcan Çakır |
| Ouattara, Agbadou, Emirhan Topçu, Murillo | Jakobs, Bitshiabu, Sánchez, Singo |
| Orkun Kökçü, Salih Özcan, Miretti | Sara, Nhaga |
| Trossard, Vlahović, Poku | Leão, Batrakov, Yunus Akgün |
| Osimhen |
Results change as the squad data changes and when you pick a different XI; the figures below are a snapshot of these settings.
At Tüpraş: Beşiktaş a step ahead
| Result | Share |
|---|---|
| Beşiktaş win | 38.9% |
| Draw | 26.5% |
| Galatasaray win | 34.6% |
At Dolmabahçe the gap is 4.3 points, forty-three matches in a thousand. Goals per match 1.43 to 1.36, expected goals (xG) 1.43 to 1.36, shots 11.7 to 11.4, possession 51% to 49%. None of it amounts to a clear gap: the engine sees Beşiktaş as only slight favourites at Tüpraş.
The most common score was 1-1 (13.7% of matches), followed by 1-0 (9.7%), 2-1 (9.2%), 1-2 (8.6%), 0-1 (7.4%) and 2-2 (7.4%). All six are one-goal margins or draws.
What happens when the venue changes?
We played the same two squads with the same settings on neutral ground and then at Galatasaray's home.
| Venue | Beşiktaş win | Draw | Galatasaray win | Average score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tüpraş (Beşiktaş at home) | 38.9% | 26.5% | 34.6% | 1.43 – 1.36 |
| Neutral ground | 30.1% | 27.2% | 42.7% | 1.28 – 1.57 |
| RAMS Park (Galatasaray at home) | 22.5% | 28.3% | 49.2% | 1.12 – 1.71 |
On neutral ground Galatasaray are the favourites on paper: 42.7% to 30.1%. In the engine's eyes Galatasaray have the stronger squad, and Beşiktaş's edge at Tüpraş comes entirely from home advantage. Playing at home adds 8.8 points to Beşiktaş's win rate and 6.5 points to Galatasaray's.
The difference between the two extremes is large: Beşiktaş win 39% at Tüpraş and 23% at RAMS Park. Same eleven players, only the stadium changed. Having this derby at Dolmabahçe is, in the engine's maths, Beşiktaş's biggest asset.
Who scores the goals?
The top scorers across the 1,000 matches at Tüpraş:
| Player | Team | Goals in 1,000 matches |
|---|---|---|
| Dušan Vlahović | Beşiktaş | 375 |
| Victor Osimhen | Galatasaray | 357 |
| Ernest Poku | Beşiktaş | 329 |
| Aleksey Batrakov | Galatasaray | 264 |
| Leandro Trossard | Beşiktaş | 243 |
| Rafael Leão | Galatasaray | 223 |
| Yunus Akgün | Galatasaray | 188 |
| Orkun Kökçü | Beşiktaş | 131 |
The two strikers are almost level: Vlahović 375, Osimhen 357. The difference is behind them. Beşiktaş's goals are concentrated in the front three, with Vlahović, Poku and Trossard scoring two thirds of them. At Galatasaray, Batrakov, Leão and Yunus Akgün share the load behind Osimhen. Worth keeping in mind when building a squad: a team that leans on three forwards loses more when one of them is missing.
Derby details
- Red cards. In the Tüpraş scenario, at least one player was sent off in 30% of matches. There were around four yellow cards per match.
- Clean sheets. Beşiktaş kept a clean sheet in 24.8% of matches, Galatasaray in 21.1%.
- Goalless draws are rare. 0-0 did not make the top six scores at Tüpraş; on neutral ground it was fifth at 6.8%.
What these numbers do and do not mean
What they mean: the engine sees these two squads as close, but puts Galatasaray ahead on neutral ground; playing the derby at Beşiktaş's home flips that balance. A single change to an XI or a different formation can tip a match this even.
What they do not mean: this is not a prediction. The simulation knows nothing about form, injured or suspended players, the coach's plan on the day or what a derby atmosphere does to players. It calculates squad strength from positions and market values. Saying ‘Beşiktaş have a 39% chance’ would be wrong; the accurate statement is ‘with these settings, this engine gave Beşiktaş 389 of the 1,000 matches at Tüpraş’. The results should not be used as betting advice.
We ran the same experiment for Fenerbahçe v Galatasaray; Galatasaray's neutral-ground win rate was around 42% there too. Why a single match is so misleading is covered in our expected goals explainer.
Try it yourself
You can repeat the experiment with your own starting XI. The Beşiktaş lineup builder and Galatasaray lineup builder open with the current squads loaded. Some ideas:
- 1Put Vlahović on the bench for Beşiktaş and play the match a few times to see how the goals spread across the front three.
- 2Set Galatasaray up in a 4-3-3 instead of a 4-2-3-1 and watch how midfield control changes.
- 3Switch the venue from Tüpraş to neutral and measure home advantage for yourself.
Look at the average of at least five or ten matches, not one; that is the whole lesson of this article.
Starting shapes to try on the pitch
Open this setup, then change the players and make it your own.
Open this setup, then change the players and make it your own.
Play the derby with your own XI
Both squads load ready. Change the starting elevens, pick the venue and watch the match minute by minute.
More articles
Real Madrid–Barcelona: a 3,000-match experiment with open records
Two fixed lineups, three venues, 3,000 simulations. Explore the results, exact squads, uncertainty and downloadable match records from our Clásico experiment.
How much is home advantage worth? We played seven fixtures 21,000 times
The same two squads at three venues. Seven big fixtures simulated a thousand times each at home, on neutral ground and away: what home advantage is worth, and when it does nothing.
Rain, wind and snow: how weather changes a football match
We played the same Clásico a thousand times each in clear weather, rain, wind and snow. How goals, pass accuracy and shots changed, and how to pick a team for bad weather.