When should you make substitutions? Getting the most from five changes
The 60th minute or the 75th? How fatigue, the score and bookings shape the timing of a substitution, who should come off, and how to plan a bench before kick-off.
Seventy minutes gone, 1-1. The coach turns to the bench and tells two players to warm up. Everyone in the stand has a name in mind; some point at the tired winger, others at the centre-back on a yellow card. The change is made and five minutes later there is a goal. The side that scored calls it inspired, the side that conceded calls it too late. In truth the decision was usually made long before, when the squad was picked.
What five substitutions changed
With three changes, the bench was insurance: one injury, one booking risk and perhaps one tactical move. Since five became permanent, the bench has been part of the game plan. If you can replace half the outfield players, you can play the last half hour with something close to a new team.
Five substitutions do not mean five stoppages, though. The rules allow changes at three separate moments during the match, with half-time not counted. That is why most teams make double and triple changes. A side that uses its windows early on single swaps may be unable to replace a player who is injured late on.
Fatigue comes before the score
The positions that run the most are usually full-backs, wing-backs and central midfielders. In a high-tempo match their number of sprints drops clearly after the hour. Whatever the score, balls played behind a tired full-back start to become dangerous.
Waiting until things go wrong is therefore waiting too long. In a match that is going well, two fresh players around the 60th to 65th minute can keep the tempo high enough to protect the result. Acting before the mistake is cheaper than waiting for a tired player to make it.
Who comes on depends on the score
The same bench is used differently according to the scoreboard.
When leading
The aim is to keep the ball in the opponent's half and protect defensive distances. Taking off a forward for a centre-back is not always right; with nobody to hold the ball up front, the defence is under constant pressure. A winger who can run or a striker who can shield the ball is often more useful than a sixth defender.
When trailing
Swapping a defender for a forward adds a body in the box but may remove the players who carry the ball there. Look at the problem first: is the ball reaching the area with nobody to finish, or is it not arriving at all? In the first case a forward helps; in the second, a midfielder or winger who progresses play is the better change.
When level
This is the hardest call because it can go either way. If the opponent is tiring, a fresh winger can turn the match; if your own side is losing its shape, an extra midfielder comes first.
Deciding who comes off
Decide by job, not by name. These questions help:
- Is anyone on a yellow card matched against the opponent's quickest player?
- Who has stopped making recovery runs?
- Will the replacement do the same job, or does the shape change?
- Who was the departing player marking at set pieces, and who takes that over?
The last question is forgotten most often. When a tall midfielder goes off for a small winger, the marking at the next corner changes. Goals conceded from set pieces straight after a substitution usually come from exactly that.
Plan the bench before the match
A good bench is not a smaller copy of the starting XI. Instead of three midfielders with the same profile, think of players who solve different problems:
| Profile | When to use | What it gives |
|---|---|---|
| Quick winger | When the opponent tires, last 25 minutes | Runs in behind and a counter-attacking threat |
| Hold-up striker | When leading and under pressure | Keeps clearances up the pitch |
| Defensive midfielder | Protecting a lead | Screens the box and collects second balls |
| Creative player | Against a deep defence | Passes between the lines and the final ball |
| Versatile defender | Injury or booking | Covers two positions with one change |
Substitutions in the simulator
In the DreamerBuild match simulator, substitutions and injuries are part of the match; tired players are replaced from the bench. Looking at the substitutes as well as the starting XI therefore affects the result. Playing the same eleven a few times with a weak bench and then a strong one, and comparing the last twenty minutes, is a worthwhile experiment.
Starting shapes to try on the pitch
Open this setup, then change the players and make it your own.
Open this setup, then change the players and make it your own.
Plan the bench, then play the match
Set your starting XI and substitutes, then watch how the changes affect the game.
More articles
Penalty shootouts: who should take them, and in what order?
Luck or preparation? We simulated 2,000 knockout matches: how many go to penalties, what share of kicks are scored and how to order your five takers.
How the offside rule works: the line, the moment of the pass and VAR
An offside position and an offside offence are not the same thing. The three conditions, the situations people confuse, the offside trap and what the VAR line measures, with a diagram.
Striker types: target man, false nine, runner and poacher
Four different centre-forwards, four different teams. What each type does, who should play alongside and which one suits your squad, with a comparison table.